top of page

November Planning and Zoning Commission Meeting -Density, Infill and Possible Demolition of Two Historic Homes to Build Townhomes

7d
3 min read
rendering of proposed development
rendering of proposed development

Loveland’s Planning and Zoning Commission met on Monday night and took up a new application for a Special Planning District (SPD) to be located along Oak Street and Hanna Avenue, within the city’s Historical District, between the city’s water tower and Hanna. Ed Farruggia, developer for TJV Properties, spoke to the Commission, along with several residents.


The proposed district would require demolition of two existing houses within Loveland's Historic Preservation and Planning District-- one dating back to 1843 (pre-Loveland, Village of Paxton) with the other being pre-1900 era -- to accommodate 13 townhouse units on 1.05 acres. The frontage would be along Oak Street, with 5 feet setbacks along Hanna and the water tower property line. One resident spoke about multiple traffic issues along with at least one building having street access problems.


Discussion from the Commission ranged from density concerns (13 attached townhomes vs 3 under current zoning) to questioning why a special planning district is being requested and if it meets the heart of the zoning code. Assistant City Manager Chris Wojnicz introduced the proposal and the initial phase of the SPD proposal; initiation of the process, according to Loveland Code Section  1129.01. 


Commission member Rob Weisgerber pointed out that it seemed like the applicant was hanging on one word in the code - creative. It was noted that the applicant requested to go through the SPD process. The developer compared the townhomes looking similar to the Blossom Hill units located on State Route 48. Weisgerber inquired whether these homes would be rentals. The applicant owns and rents 10 single family homes in Loveland, 8 in the Heights and Stoneybrook subdivisions along with the two homes in Clermont County. The developer said the proposed 13 homes would not be rental. Weisgerber asked fundamentally, is this the right thing to do overall.


Commission member Dave Parker asked about the balance between Planning and Zoning and the Historical Preservation and Planning Commission, where are they within the timeline of Planning and Zoning’s determination of the creation of a new Special Planning District and, if it is created, where do they exist in the development of the SPD? The administration addressed it as a back and forth movement between the two.


Lynn Zuch, a new Commission member this year, stated a concern regarding the density. Andy Bateman, Commission member and Vice Mayor, referenced the density with the neighboring apartment buildings along Oak and Hanna. For this initiation phase, it just needs to tip the scales ever so slightly for him, that this proposal represents below the average of the density of apartments, collective while keeping the neighboring homes in sight. Bateman stated the public hearing would get us closer to the initiation of an SPD but this is incrementally moving this forward at the applicant’s request.


Chair Mark Redmond agreed with the incremental process comment, highlighting the other SPD project several properties down from these townhomes and the multiple years that process took.


The Planning and Zoning Commission voted 3-2 (Redmond, Bateman and Palmer in favor, Weisgerber and Zuch voting no) that the application satisfies the first section of code for the process of creation of a special planning district for this development. There will be at least two public hearings on this proposal, with both Planning and Zoning and the Historical Preservation hearing from the residents, property owners and developer. 


What do you think?  Loveland Daily News would like to hear from you. Send us your comments at news@lovelanddailynews.com. We may publish your comments in a future article.


Current property map of Oak Street and Hanna Avenue






Proposed 13 Townhomes at Oak Street and Hanna Avenue


 
 
 

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating

Subscribe to our Weekly Edition

WEEKLY EDITION EVERY WEDNESDAY. 

Straight To Your Inbox.

unnamed.jpg
Connecting You to The Heart of Loveland
  • White Facebook Icon
  • YouTube
bottom of page